Water Street: One Tiny Alley, Many Different Visions

At a lively Pedestrian and Bicycle Advisory Committee meeting Wednesday, businesses disagreed over whether to open Water Street to through traffic. Proponents say it will create parking, but critics say it will ruin the feel of the area.

The city’s plan to allow traffic on Water Street was supposed to appease downtown merchants who have long pushed for more parking.

But the idea has set off a firestorm of criticism from business owners and residents who are worried that the city’s plan will ruin the feel of the waterfront and be a step backward in the city’s effort to make itself more pedestrian and bicycle-friendly.

On Wednesday, both sides sounded off at a lively Pedestrian and Bicycle Advisory Committee meeting at the Lucchesi Community Center, where the overwhelming majority of business owners spoke out against the plan to allow cars to travel on Water Street and exit at Western Avenue.

Among those in attendance were Holly Wick, who owns , at the corner of Petaluma Boulevard North and Western Avenue and Stephanie Rastetter, the proprietor of . Both oppose the plan, which grew out of the city’s road diet project that will reduce Petaluma Boulevard from four to two lanes between E and East Washington streets.

“Eight parking places isn’t going to do anything except ruin the place (Water Street),” said an exasperated Rastetter, adding that many of her customers now enjoy patio dining that would be marred by cars passing by.

“If you really want to change things downtown, get rid of the two hour parking restriction.”

Basha Quilici, the owner of the recently approved on Western Avenue Extension (and next door to Water Street Bistro) said she was dismayed to find out that her soon to open business, which will also feature patio dining, would now look out onto a street with cars.

“I would not have chosen that location if I knew this was going to be put in,” Quilici said.

Several seats over, Petaluma Downtown Association director Marie McCusker was equally exasperated.

“When we proposed this plan we were trying to appease the merchants who in earlier surveys and meetings said they wanted more parking,” McCusker said. “And now all these other businesses are coming out against it. I feel like we are caught in the middle and are damned if we support the project and damned if we don’t.”

McCusker described Water Street as unsuitable for a true pedestrian thoroughfare, largely because of the uneven cobblestones that make it difficult to cycle, walk or even push a stroller across. She said the cobblestone was put in about a decade ago using redevelopment monies, but is so rough and bumpy that it’s become a liability for the city.

“Water Street is just not suitable for any events; it’s a dead area,” she said. “Now it’s mostly used by kids sitting there in the dark or by homeless people.”

The only business present at the meeting and in favor of opening Water Street to cars was Will Mendoza, owner of . Mendoza said that in his eight years as owner of two buildings in the area, there has never been a special event on Water Street.

“It’s an underused space and as a merchant, all I’m saying is ‘We need more parking,’” he said.

Others criticized the plan, saying opening up Water Street (south of Washington Street) to cars was ridiculous, considering the proposed trestle and walkway that will eventually be put in next to the Balshaw Bridge. They said that downtown already has two parking structures—the Keller Street garage and the parking lot at Theater Square—which seldom filled up.

“I’d like for us to imagine a Water Street without any cars on it,” said Eric Backman, a member of Friends of the Petaluma River, a local organization focused on reconnecting residents with the waterway.

“It wouldn’t hurt for Petalumans to walk a little further…Ultimately downtown businesses flourish when more people are in the area,” he said.

The Bicycle and Pedestrian Advisory Committee plans on making numerous recommendations to City Council, including offering four-hour parking in Theater Square, adding more handicapped parking spots, issuing permits to cars that have to access Water Street for delivery purposes and ticketing everybody else and smoothing the Water Street cobblestones as much as possible to make walking on Water Street easier.

What’s your vision for Water Street?

Seana Gause July 12, 2012 at 02:46 PM
Water Street should remain open to pedestrians and delivery trucks only. The street hasn't been used for an event because we are in a recession. There used to be a River Festival held on Water Street and it was a fantastic event full of music and food and fun. Once there are resources to plan and hold an event like that again I have no doubt it will occur. To open Water Street up to parking and vehicular traffic is a step backwards and not in the best interest of creating an inviting waterfront. The City has benefitted weekly from the Yacht Club's ability to book the dock along the river and have people moor their boats all weekend. That prospect would be MUCH less appealing if there were constant traffic on Water Street.
Bookworm July 12, 2012 at 02:57 PM
I disagree with this comment by Marie McCusker: “Water Street is just not suitable for any events; it’s a dead area,” she said. “Now it’s mostly used by kids sitting there in the dark or by homeless people.” That might be true at 1 am, but when I have been there at other times, it has looked like families were enjoying it.
Jeff Muchow July 12, 2012 at 03:25 PM
There are 2 parking garages within short walking distance of downtown businesses. While the additional parking might be nice, it will change what is now a pedestrian friendly area and that is bad. The merchants need to understand that part of the appeal of downtown is that it is pedestrian friendly...don't take a step backwards by opening Water Street!
Bill Fishman July 12, 2012 at 04:59 PM
Actually, Water Street has been used for some nice events: It has been the beginning point for the annual Dia De Los Muertos observance and procession; and for a year it was the site of Friday Night Jazz with customers of both the Water Street Grill and Central Market enjoying music and outdoor dining. Hey, it ain't the Seine ; but it's the only waterfront we have. (Maybe we could dye the river green on St Patrick's Day!)
Joe Manthey July 12, 2012 at 07:21 PM
There was also a wine tasting/live music event on Water Street four years ago. This morphed into The Petaluma Music Festival.
Tyler Young July 12, 2012 at 07:36 PM
We held an event on Water Street (Artist & Farmers) a few years ago, the photos of the day are beautiful, it looked like a street in Paris. The problem is the cobblestone, it was installed upside down. Because it's so rough, we couldn't find insurance for the event. We had to impose on the businesses to front the insurance. My two cents, let's rip out the cobblestone and reclaim Water Street!
Chad M. July 12, 2012 at 07:50 PM
Who would have thought Cobblestone could cause so much trouble!
Rosanna July 12, 2012 at 08:14 PM
If there is enough parking in the Keller Street Lot and in the Theater District Lot and folks think people should walk more, then why don't you designate more handicap spaces on Kentucky and Petaluma Blvd. and let the able bodied walk from the underused parking lots? And you can leave Water Street as it is. I'd come downtown a lot more if I thought there was a chance to find handicap parking along the street near the place I want to visit. There is a period of time when progressive arthritis may not, yet, require a wheelchair, but, nevertheless, necessitates limited walking. More handicap parking would help enormously - and keep the wheelchair away longer.
Karina Ioffee July 12, 2012 at 08:14 PM
Yes, that darned cobblestone, put in for aesthetic reasons. We have a post coming shortly about the history of those stones and the logic behind them. I'm sure it made sense to SOMEBODY at the time!!
The Fool July 13, 2012 at 06:20 AM
Let's go a step farther. Could we restrict cars on Kentucky?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something